Skip to content
CostPerKWh

Tiered Electricity Pricing vs. Time-of-Use Plans Explained

How tiers and peak hours change what each kWh costs, with worked bills, and how to tell which plan suits your home.

By Juan Antonio Fernández Selma · Published November 18, 2026 · Figures use EIA data for August 2026

Two homes can use exactly the same number of kilowatt-hours in a month and pay very different bills. Part of the reason is where they live: the U.S. Energy Information Administration's average residential price was 18.16¢ per kWh in August 2026, but state averages vary several-fold. The other part is the rate structure, the rules your utility uses to price each kWh. The two most common alternatives to a simple flat rate are tiered pricing, which charges more as you use more, and time-of-use pricing, which charges more at certain hours. This guide explains how each works, walks through the same month priced on each, and shows how to decide which one suits you.

The baseline: a flat rate

On a flat rate, every kWh costs the same no matter how many you use or when you use them. The bill is simple: a fixed monthly customer charge plus kWh × price. Flat rates are still the default in much of the Southeast, Midwest and Mountain West. They are easy to understand but give no reward for using power when it is cheapest to produce and deliver, which is why regulators in many states are moving away from them.

How tiered (inclining block) rates work

A tiered rate divides each month's usage into blocks. The first block, often called the baseline or tier 1, is priced lowest. Usage above it falls into a higher-priced tier, and some utilities have three or more tiers. The idea is that a basic amount of electricity for lighting, refrigeration and cooking should be affordable, while heavy discretionary use pays more.

What sets the tier size

The size of the first tier is usually set by climate zone, season and sometimes heating type. California's investor-owned utilities, for example, give each customer a daily baseline allowance that is larger in hot inland zones in summer and for all-electric homes in winter. Elsewhere, a common design charges a higher price for usage above 1,000 kWh a month, which mostly affects large homes with electric heat or heavy air conditioning. Florida Power & Light and several Southern utilities use this kind of threshold.

What tiers mean for your decisions

Under a tiered rate, the price of the next kWh is what matters for any decision. If your usage regularly lands in the top tier, every kWh you save is worth the top-tier price, not the average. That makes efficiency upgrades pay back faster for heavy users and makes it important to look at your marginal price, not your average, when estimating savings.

How time-of-use rates work

Time-of-use (TOU) rates price electricity by the hour of the day, and often by season. A typical plan has a peak window, commonly 4 to 9 p.m. or 2 to 7 p.m. on weekdays, when prices are highest; an off-peak period overnight and on weekends; and sometimes a mid-peak or shoulder period in between. Some EV-focused plans add a super off-peak window, often midnight to 6 a.m., with very low prices.

The reason is cost. Utilities must build and pay for enough generation, transmission and distribution capacity to meet the highest demand of the year, which usually falls on hot summer afternoons and early evenings, or on the coldest winter mornings in heating-dominated regions. Power used at those hours costs much more to supply. In states with a lot of solar, midday power is now abundant and cheap, and the expensive hours have moved later, to when the sun goes down but air conditioners are still running.

Variations you may see

The same month on three plans

To compare the structures fairly, take one home using 900 kWh in a month, a little above the national average of 863 kWh (EIA, 2024). The prices below are illustrative, chosen to be typical of plans that average out to similar revenue for the utility; your utility's numbers will differ. Customer charges are left out because they are the same on all three.

PlanHow the 900 kWh are pricedEnergy costAverage ¢/kWh
Flat900 kWh × $0.17$153.0017.0¢
Tiered600 kWh × $0.15 + 300 kWh × $0.22$156.0017.3¢
TOU, typical habits (25% at peak)225 kWh × $0.36 + 675 kWh × $0.13$168.7518.8¢
TOU, shifted habits (12% at peak)108 kWh × $0.36 + 792 kWh × $0.13$141.8415.8¢

Working through the math

The tiered bill: the first 600 kWh cost 600 × $0.15 = $90.00; the remaining 300 kWh cost 300 × $0.22 = $66.00; total $156.00. The home's marginal price is 22¢, even though its average is 17.3¢.

The TOU bill with typical habits: a quarter of the use, 225 kWh, falls in the peak window at 36¢, costing $81.00; the other 675 kWh cost 13¢, or $87.75. Total: $168.75. If the household moves laundry, dishwashing and EV charging out of the peak and pre-cools the house before 4 p.m., the peak share might fall to 12%, and the same 900 kWh cost $141.84.

The break-even share

A quick way to judge a TOU plan: find the share of your use at peak where the TOU plan costs the same as the flat rate. With these prices it is (flat − off-peak) ÷ (peak − off-peak) = (17 − 13) ÷ (36 − 13) = 17%. A home using less than 17% of its electricity in peak hours saves money on TOU; a home using more pays extra. Many households fall between 15 and 25%, which is why the result depends heavily on habits and on what runs in the late afternoon.

Who wins on each structure

HouseholdTieredTime-of-use
Small apartment, low useBenefits: most use stays in the cheap tierNeutral to slightly worse if home in the evening
Large home with electric heatPays a lot of top-tier kWhDepends on heating hours; morning peaks hurt
EV owner charging overnightCharging pushes usage into top tiersBig winner, especially with super off-peak
Works from home, AC all afternoonNeutralOften worse unless the house is pre-cooled
Rooftop solar with batteryNeutralWinner: battery covers the peak
Retirees home all day in a hot climateNeutralRisky: check the peak window carefully

How to choose: a five-step check

  1. Download your interval data. If you have a smart meter, your utility's website usually lets you download hourly or 15-minute usage, often as a "Green Button" file. Twelve months is ideal.
  2. Calculate your peak share. Add up the kWh used during the plan's peak hours and divide by your total. Do this for a summer month and a winter month at least.
  3. Price your year on each plan. Many utilities have an online rate comparison tool that does this automatically using your own data. Use it before switching.
  4. Identify what you could move. Dryers, dishwashers, pool pumps, water heaters and EV charging are easy to shift with timers. Cooking and evening lighting are not.
  5. Check the switching rules. Some utilities let you try TOU with bill protection for the first year, refunding the difference if you would have paid less on your old rate.

Making a TOU plan pay

What the EIA's averages do and do not tell you

The state averages published by the EIA, and used throughout this site, are total residential revenue divided by total kWh sold. They blend every rate structure in the state, every tier and every hour. That makes them a reliable "all-in" average for estimating a typical bill, but it hides the marginal price you face on a tiered or TOU plan. When you estimate savings from a change, use the price that applies to the kWh you are changing: the top-tier price on a tiered plan, or the peak price for use you move out of the peak window.

To see what any appliance costs at your own price, open the electricity cost calculator, pick the appliance and type the peak or top-tier price from your bill in the rate box. Compare it with the off-peak price to see what moving that appliance is worth. To find what utilities near you charge, use the rate finder by ZIP code.

Sources