Rooftop solar is a large purchase that pays you back slowly, in electricity you no longer buy. How slowly depends on three things more than on the panels themselves: how much your utility charges per kWh, how much sunshine your roof gets, and what your utility pays for the power you send back to the grid. Because U.S. electricity prices vary several-fold between states, the same system can pay for itself in under ten years in one state and take more than twenty in another. This guide explains the payback math, works through an example, and estimates payback for twelve states at the EIA's August 2026 residential prices.
The simple payback formula
Simple payback is the installed cost divided by the money the system saves each year:
payback (years) = net installed cost ÷ yearly bill savings
Yearly savings, in turn, are the system's yearly output in kWh multiplied by what each of those kWh is worth to you. That value is where states differ most.
Step 1: estimate yearly output
Each kilowatt of panels produces roughly 1,000 to 1,700 kWh a year in the U.S., depending on latitude, weather, roof direction, tilt and shading. A south-facing roof in Arizona sits at the top of that range; a partly shaded roof in Seattle near the bottom. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory's free PVWatts calculator gives a good estimate for your address.
Step 2: value each kWh
Solar power you use the moment it is produced replaces power you would have bought at your full retail price. Power you export is credited according to your utility's rules:
- Full retail net metering: each exported kWh earns a credit equal to the retail price, so all output is worth the full rate.
- Net billing or avoided-cost credits: exported kWh earn a lower credit, often a quarter to a half of retail, sometimes varying by hour. California moved new customers to this model in 2023, and several other states have followed with their own versions.
Step 3: subtract incentives
The 30% federal tax credit for homeowner-owned systems (Section 25D) ended for systems installed after December 31, 2025. Some states, utilities and cities still offer rebates, performance payments or property tax exemptions, and leased systems and power purchase agreements are priced by companies that may still claim business credits. Check what applies where you live.
Worked example: Texas
- System: 7 kW at $3.00 per watt = $21,000 installed, with no rebate.
- Output: 7 kW × 1,450 kWh per kW = 10,150 kWh a year.
- Value with full retail net metering at Texas's average 15.91¢: 10,150 × $0.1591 = $1,615 a year.
- Payback: $21,000 ÷ $1,615 = 13.0 years.
- With net billing, where 40% of output is used at home and exports earn 30% of retail: savings fall to $937 a year and payback stretches to 22.4 years.
Texas has no statewide net metering requirement, so export credits depend entirely on your utility or retail plan; some offer buyback plans near retail, others pay little.
Estimated payback in 12 states
Same 7 kW system and cost in every state, valued at each state's average residential price for August 2026. The yield figures are rough statewide values; your roof may differ by 20% or more either way. The net billing column assumes the 40/60 split and 30% export value described above.
| State | Rate | kWh/kW/yr | Yearly output | Savings, full net metering | Payback | Payback, net billing |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hawaii | 47.2¢ | 1,450 | 10,150 kWh | $4,789 | 4.4 yrs | 7.6 yrs |
| California | 29.8¢ | 1,550 | 10,850 kWh | $3,228 | 6.5 yrs | 11.2 yrs |
| Massachusetts | 30.5¢ | 1,200 | 8,400 kWh | $2,560 | 8.2 yrs | 14.1 yrs |
| New York | 28.6¢ | 1,150 | 8,050 kWh | $2,306 | 9.1 yrs | 15.7 yrs |
| New Jersey | 24.6¢ | 1,200 | 8,400 kWh | $2,067 | 10.2 yrs | 17.5 yrs |
| Colorado | 17.2¢ | 1,500 | 10,500 kWh | $1,803 | 11.6 yrs | 20.1 yrs |
| Arizona | 15.1¢ | 1,700 | 11,900 kWh | $1,791 | 11.7 yrs | 20.2 yrs |
| Illinois | 19.3¢ | 1,200 | 8,400 kWh | $1,623 | 12.9 yrs | 22.3 yrs |
| Texas | 15.9¢ | 1,450 | 10,150 kWh | $1,615 | 13.0 yrs | 22.4 yrs |
| Georgia | 15.9¢ | 1,350 | 9,450 kWh | $1,503 | 14.0 yrs | 24.1 yrs |
| Florida | 15.0¢ | 1,400 | 9,800 kWh | $1,469 | 14.3 yrs | 24.6 yrs |
| Washington | 14.6¢ | 1,050 | 7,350 kWh | $1,075 | 19.5 yrs | 33.7 yrs |
The pattern is clear: the electricity price matters more than the sunshine. High-price states with only average sun, such as Massachusetts and New York, can beat sunny states with cheap power. Hawaii, with the highest prices in the country, pays back fastest despite strict export rules on its island grids, because almost every kWh used at home replaces very expensive power. Washington, with cheap hydropower and gray winters, takes longest.
What else changes the answer
Rising electricity prices
Simple payback assumes today's price forever. U.S. residential prices rose to 18.16¢ in August 2026 from 17.57¢ a year earlier, according to the EIA. If prices keep rising 2 to 3% a year, every year's savings grow and payback shortens by a year or more. The reverse is also possible where regulators shift more of the bill into fixed charges, which solar cannot offset.
Batteries
Under net billing, a battery lets you store midday solar and use it during the evening peak instead of exporting it for a low credit. That raises the value of each kWh but adds $10,000 or more to the cost. Batteries pay back best on time-of-use plans with a large gap between peak and off-peak prices, and they provide backup power during outages, which has value of its own.
Degradation, maintenance and roof work
Panels typically lose about 0.5% of output a year. Inverters may need replacing once during a system's 25 to 30 year life. If your roof will need replacing in the next decade, do it before installing panels; removing and reinstalling them later costs thousands.
Financing
A loan adds interest; a lease or power purchase agreement replaces the upfront cost with monthly payments and changes the comparison entirely. With a lease, compare the monthly payment and escalator against the bill savings rather than computing payback.
Beyond simple payback: lifetime savings
Simple payback answers when you break even, not how much you come out ahead. A system with a 10-year payback and a 25-year life produces about 15 more years of savings after it has paid for itself, minus an inverter replacement. Using the worked example for Texas, $1,615 a year of savings over 25 years, reduced by panel degradation, comes to roughly $37,949 before any change in electricity prices, against a $21,000 system cost. Financial planners often compare that stream of savings with what the same money would earn elsewhere; at current electricity prices, solar in high-price states usually compares well, while in low-price states the return can be modest.
Before you sign: a checklist
- Get at least three quotes and compare the price per watt, panel and inverter brands, and warranties.
- Ask the installer which net metering or export tariff you will be on, in writing.
- Check your last 12 months of usage; a system much larger than your use earns only export credits for the excess.
- Cut usage first: efficiency upgrades are cheaper per kWh than panels and let you buy a smaller system.
- Confirm any state or utility rebates and how long they will last.
Find your numbers
Look up your state's average price on the electricity rates by state page, or your own utility's rate with the ZIP code rate finder. Use the kWh to dollars calculator to value your expected yearly output at your price, then divide the quoted system cost by that figure for your simple payback.
Frequently asked questions
What is a good payback period for solar panels?
Panels typically last 25 to 30 years, so any simple payback under about 12 years leaves well over a decade of nearly free electricity. Paybacks of 6 to 10 years are common in high-price states with good export credits; 15 years or more is common where electricity is cheap or exports are credited at low values.
Does solar make sense in states with cheap electricity?
It is harder. Each kWh the panels produce saves only what you would have paid for it, so in states with prices near 12¢ per kWh, payback can stretch beyond 15 years without local incentives. Solar can still make sense for homeowners who value backup power with a battery, expect prices to rise, or have unusually low installation costs.
What is the difference between net metering and net billing?
Under net metering, each kWh you export earns a credit equal to the retail price, so exported and self-used solar are worth the same. Under net billing, exports earn a lower credit, often tied to wholesale prices or avoided costs, so solar is worth most when used in the home as it is produced or stored in a battery for the evening.
Do solar panels work on cloudy days?
Yes, at reduced output. Panels respond to light rather than heat, and on overcast days they may produce 10 to 25% of their clear-day output. Yearly production estimates from tools like NREL's PVWatts already account for typical local weather, including cloudy seasons.
